Letter to the editor: Why DEI is misunderstood

Editor’s note: The Portager publishes letters to the editor from the community. The opinions expressed are published not because they necessarily reflect those of the publication but because we feel they contribute meaningfully to the local discourse on matters of public interest.

I attended the Property Tax meeting hosted by Project Promise where elimination of DEI was cheered. I also read The Portager’s reporting on state Rep. Demetriou’s celebratory comments about elimination of DEI employees. I truly believe that a lot of people’s opinion of DEI is severely misconstrued and misunderstood.

Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI) has become another trigger expression for the racial inequality in our country from its’ inception and in many ways continuing even today.

DEI was and is a movement to ensure that all people in our country have equal opportunities as our Constitution and Bill of Rights intended. DEI is NOT intended to discriminate against any race, gender or religion. DEI is NOT keeping any qualified person from applying or being employed by any company or business. And DEI has not kept anyone “down” as so many people believe. And currently the firing of inspectors general is a move to ensure that abuse is not recognized. IGs’ sole purpose in the government are to report waste, fraud, and abuse.

The 14th Amendment of the Constitution is the Equal Protection Act. This amendment guarantees equal rights of every citizen regardless of race or ethnicity. DEI was the checks and balances for this part of the 14th Amendment. Elimination of DEI employees by Donald Trump goes against the Constitution and his oath of office to support the Constitution. And Rep. Demetriou’s celebration of elimination of DEI employees goes against his oath of office to uphold the Constitution.

Going back to the Project Promise meeting. I was totally surprised by the speaker who preached to the attendees about the biblical references to property taxes. In my opinion this person has skewed the teachings of the Lord and Jesus Christ as written in the Bible. Our country was designed and intended as a secular nation. Religion and politics are not to be intermixed. Religion is personal choice. Religion can guide your personal life. There is a very good reason why the founders kept any reference of God or religion out of the Constitution. In fact many of the founders were deists. Deism is a philosophical position based on reason rather than any revelation or church authority. Our country needs to stay as a secular nation and support all or no religious preference by everyone.

— Thurl Carmany, Brimfield

+ posts

The Portager publishes a range of opinions from the community. To submit a letter to the editor, write to [email protected].

  1. Ben, please pass on my thanks to Thurl Carmany for the remarks in the Wednesday Portager. They are sane, lucid, and all too seldom stated publicly, while the people who misquote and misapply the Bible are out there all the time. The United States was NOT founded as a Christian nation. Read the First Amendment to the Bill of Rights!
    Thank you for doing The Portager.

  2. Thanks to Thurl Carmany for bringing up this irrelevant and irreverent comment made at the meeting supposedly about property tax problems.
    I personally spoke to an otherwise intelligent (you would have thought before) who believes that being “woke” is a terrible thing. This is another one of the trigger words of the far right.
    Woke was originally meant to mean that one’s eyes are now open to the injustices of so many inequalities of the past for women, people of color( sorry I do not have a better term), people of other religions, country of origin, disabilities, or so many other differences of kind or thought. Now it is just being used to mean that only white straight males who carry AR 15s are allowed to have rights.

    The writer stated it well. Thanks to him or her and to The Portager for publishing this. Your journalistic devotion to openness and truth is important.

  3. I appreciate the letter from Thurl Carmany. It is clear and factual. It is a shame that our checks and balances have been so strongly eroded by politics. These policies were put in place to protect everyone. Eliminating protections and oversight will make room for the powerful and greedy to take advantage.

  4. Great writing…..I agree 100%. MAGA is ruining our country and its Constitution. Ignorance and intolerance of others is Un American.

  5. It is apparent that the religious group sponsoring the tax meeting has an agenda that goes beyond preaching about Jesus and following the bible about love and inclusion. It is a front for MAGA. I would suggest admonishing them more and getting tax advice from tax experts and not MAGA religious extremists.

  6. I agree, church and state need to be kept separate. I can absolutely guarantee that your religion is not mine and we will never agree on anything about it but I firmly believe in the constitution and the laws of our nation and the facts that no one is above that law. DEI can always be twisted by some people for their own agenda. Getting tired of the way some are demolishing my country and government to satisfy a few greedy people.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *