By Rachel Reight
On July 13, from 1-4 p.m., the Aurora Historical Society hosted its much-anticipated Historic Home (and Garden) Tour, followed by a delightful wine and cheese event at the Aurora Historical Society. Despite the heat, the community’s enthusiasm and dedication made the event a tremendous success.
The tour began at the Deed House, originally constructed around 1805 by Ebenezer Sheldon. The deed house, now located in Pioneer Park, served as the center of Sheldon’s land transactions, helping shape the township of Aurora.
Next, attendees visited the Church in Aurora, established in 1809. The church’s construction began in 1816, spearheaded by the congregation’s first full-time minister, John Seward. Despite financial and weather-related delays, the church was completed in 1824. The original brick structure, built on land donated by Samuel Forward, was later replaced by a wooden structure in 1871.
Adjacent to the church stands Aurora Town Hall, originally Aurora Center School No. 5, built between 1883 and 1886. After Aurora centralized its school system, the building was sold to the township in 1914 and repurposed as a town hall.
Built in 1890 for David and Mary Riley, the Riley House is a testament to Aurora’s historic district. David and his family played significant roles in the community.
The Queen Anne-style home, also known as the “Green Monster” or “Buttercup Manor” was built by Willis J. Eldridge, one of Aurora’s prominent “Cheese Barons.” Eldridge’s rivalry with fellow cheese magnate Frank Hurd marked Aurora’s “Golden Age” of the cheese industry, which lasted nearly a century.
The James Jewett House/Cobbler’s Cottage bought by James M. Jewett in 1846, has deep historical roots, including being a training site for the Ohio Militia during the War of 1812.
The tour also featured the City of Aurora Landscape award-winning garden of the Frank Hurd House. The serene oasis, with its stone pathway and tiered fountain, provided a peaceful retreat for visitors.
The historic Converse Store, preserved by the City of Aurora, offered a glimpse into early 19th-century commerce, where whiskey was a top seller and a staple for medicinal purposes.
We extend our heartfelt thanks to all sponsors, volunteers, and community members for their generous support and dedication. Your participation made this event truly memorable. If you’re interested in joining the Aurora Historical Society or helping plan the 2025 Historic Home (and Garden) Tour, please reach out to [email protected].
